Rabbi Malkhi was followed by Rabbi Raphael Carigal of Hebron who visited twice in 1771 and 1773, and then, two years later, by Rabbi Samuel Cohen of Jerusalem. But it was Rabbi Carigal who left a lasting impression in colonial America. He had, previously, visited the Jews of Surinam and Curacao and had, at one time, officiated as Chief Rabbi of Barbados. On Shavuot 1773, he was in Yeshuat Yisrael in Newport where he gave a sermon that was attended by Joseph Wanton, the Governor of Rhode Island, and Rev. Ezra Stiles, President of Yale. Entitled “The Salvation of Israel”, it was preached in Spanish and Hebrew and became the first Jewish sermon in America to be published. It was translated by one of the leading Jewish merchants of Newport during that time, Abraham Lopez. Halukkah was suspended during the Revolutionary War, but afterwards, it resumed.
In the early decades of the 19th century, American, and American Jewish interest in active Jewish Restoration to its homeland was first aroused. This “nationalist” idea was best personified by Philadelphia-born Mordechai Manuel Noah, playwright, editor, and diplomat. As editor of the National Advocate in 1818, he was the recipient of a letter written by President John Adams in which he stated his hope that the nation of Israel will soon return to its homeland. Noah made it a point to acquaint himself with many of the Palestinian emissaries who came to the US as well as with the organizers of halukkah. In the 1820s, he declared the island of Ararat in upstate New York as a place of refuge for Jews where they would all be gathered and eventually brought to the Land of Israel. And as he considered the indigenous Americans to be descended from the ancient Israelites, indigenous Americans were invited to participate. The project failed, however, and thereafter, he advocated the immediate settlement of the ancient Jewish homeland.
During this time, thousands of Jews had immigrated to the US from German-speaking countries. Many were adventurous, being among the pioneers into the American west. The majority were reform and progressive in outlook, and had no tolerance for the orthodox way of life, the belief in the Messianic Redemption – and certainly not Halukkah which they viewed as nothing more than charity and beggary. Orthodoxy, however, was still a substantial part of this immigrant population.
From 1854-60, the Jerusalem neighborhood Mishkenot Shaananim was built. The building of this neighborhood, the bulk of which was paid for through the last will and testament of Judah Touro, the son of Isaac Touro and New Orleans businessman, was led by the British philanthropist Sir Moses Montefiore, and Gershom Kursheedt, member of the New Orleans City Council, chief executor of the Touro will, and son of Israel Baer Kursheedt.
With the opening up of the west to American settlement, Jews too joined in the migration. Along with the new Jewish communities that were established in this period, centers were also organized to deal with Jewish social and economic problems as well as halukkah. Therefore, new halukkah centers emanated from such places as Cincinnati and Denver. But it was from California that a majority of halukkah contributions originated, with San Francisco being the largest center in the western US – a result of the Gold Rush of the late 1840s. It was also from San Francisco that many of the pilgrimages to Palestine had come, such as that of Hyam Joseph in 1851, who went along with a Jewish notable from Philadelphia, IA Lehman. In the tiny pueblo of Los Angeles, the local Hebrew Benevolent Society, part of which was devoted to halukkah, was established in 1854 by Phillip Newmark, a prominent German Jewish merchant in the city, and Samuel Labatt, Sephardi merchant and pioneer from Houston. By the late 1860s, a certain Haim Sneersohn became the first emissary to reach Los Angeles by way of Washington and many other cities across America, and by the 1870s, it was said that halukkah emissaries to America had succeeded in making contact with Jewish communities from Maine to California.
After the Civil War, American interest in the Land of Israel resumed, spearheaded particularly by the Board of Delegates of American Israelites (est. 1859). The Board supported Palestinian Jewry during the cholera outbreak in 1865, and two years later, established a permanent fund for Jewish interests. They donated funding for the new Mikve Yisrael Agricultural School, built in 1870, established a Jewish hospital fund in Jerusalem, and worked with the American Consul in Jerusalem to aid Jews during the Russo-Turkish War (1877-78).
Aside from these activities, there were others who made their contributions to the Land of Israel. In 1866, a group of American evangelists from Maine and New Hampshire moved to Palestine and, with the help of the American vice-consul in Jerusalem Herman Leventhal, a convert to Christianity, founded the settlement Mount Hope outside of Jaffa. The settlers would employ local Jews, teaching them agricultural pursuits. It was their belief that such enterprises would be a first step in bringing about a massive Jewish return to Israel and with it, the Second Coming of Jesus Christ. Their efforts failed, however as their settlement was exposed to constant Arab attacks as well as the harsh elements of desert and marsh. After a year, most left Palestine disillusioned. In 1870, Simon Berman, a Polish-born American Jew, had settled in Tiberias and founded the Holy Land Settlement Society. But despite its promising start and support from many Palestinian Jewish quarters, this enterprise, too, failed. Benjamin Peixotto made a pilgrimage to Palestine in 1874 in an attempt to relieve the persecution of the Jews as he had in Romania as US Consul-General in that country.
Beginning in 1866, special emissaries were sent by the newly-formed Vaad Clali which had just been established in Jerusalem to oversee all halukkah funding and to work closely with the halukkah organizations in the United States and Canada. By the late 1870s, the North American Relief Society for the Indigent Jews of Jerusalem (est. in 1853 by the Portuguese Jewish and orthodox German Jewish communities as the successor to the Trumat haKodesh) was contributing $750 a year to Palestine, by way of the halukkah center in London, with instructions to divide the amount equally between the Ashkenazim and Sephardim. Contributions intended for Ashkenazim only, were sent directly to the Ashkenazi Chief Rabbi Samuel Salant in Jerusalem. The New York Society for the Relief of the Poor in Palestine forwarded about $1,250 a year. Baltimore congregations Chizook Emunah and the local Shearith Israel would send about $500 a year. Up to 1885, American halukkah contributions did not exceed $5,000 annually, but through the energetic work of Palestinian Rabbi Yosef Rivlin, the increase of the halukkah from America was soon apparent. Both Ashkenazim and Sephardim competed for American funds, but the Sephardim, tired of opposing the Ashkenazim in North America, decided instead, to confine their attention to the largely Sephardic centers in southern Europe, Africa, and Asia.
By the 1890s, the North American Relief Society came to be mired by law suits by those who challenged its handling of Halukkah funds. Legal costs were staggering and this resulted in the organization’s eventual disbandment. American halukkah seemed headed for demise, but not quite.In 1879, a group of American Jews who settled in Jerusalem attempted to form an American kolel with the support of the US consul in Jerusalem J.G. Wilson. Presumably, this kolel would be supported by American Jewry at the expense of the other kolelim in Palestine, and the Vaad Clali made sure to block its establishment. The Vaad was initially successful and, instead, took responsibility for the Americans’ welfare. Despite this, under the initiative of Nahum Harris, an American retiree living in Jerusalem, an American kolel was finally formed in 1896, separate from the Vaad Clali, and they called it Kolel America Tif’eret Yerushalaim. The Brisker Rebbe Yehoshua Lob Diskin was persuaded to be its spiritual head and under his guidance, contributions to Kolel America increased yearly. By 1900, membership had reached almost 300. It still exists to this day. The Vaad, fearing the consequence of this independent kolel, effected a settlement in 1901 on a basis of two-thirds for the Vaad and one-third for the Kolel from all collections made in the United States and Canada. Under this new arrangement, the total amount of the American collections for the halukkah increased and amounted to about $20,000 a year – about $5,500 after expenses.
The pogroms in Russia and throughout Eastern Europe resulted in a mass migration of Jews from that area to other parts of the world. Some 25,000 went to Palestine, a few thousand went to Argentina, but most went to the United States. Of those who went to the US, there was a core among them who followed the Zionist spirit. They became the vanguard of the Zionist movement in America, the hub of which was New York's Lower East Side where the majority of Jewish immigrants settled.
In 1882, Joseph Bluestone, a prominent physician, established there the first such society, the New York Lovers of Zion. Eliezer Bricker, treasurer of the second Zionist Society established in New York, extended much financial aid to the early pioneers in Palestine. Other Zionist societies were, later, founded, each with its own political points of view and aiding the early Palestinian pioneers in different ways. By 1900, 24 such organizations were located in New York alone, with a membership of 5000. These were the nucleus of the American Zionist Federation.
Some of the earliest supporters and members of the BILU were American Jews. But this was also a time when the Ottoman Empire was experiencing the rise of non-Turkish nationalisms within its borders. Therefore, fearing the rise of Jewish nationalism, a communication from the minister of foreign affaris was sent to Gen. Lew Wallace, United States minister to Turkey, in which the statement was made that Jews would be made welcome anywhere in Turkey except in Palestine. This was strongly opposed by Gen. Wallace and in 1884 he took vigorous action against the threatened expulsion from Palestine of the Lubrowsky brothers, naturalized American citizens. In 1887 and 1888 attempts were made by the Turkish government to limit the sojourn of American Jews in Jerusalem to one month—later extended to three months. This was opposed, as well, by Wallace’s successor, Oscar Straus, a Jew. Due to the support given him by Secretary of State Bayard, (and later, by Secretaries Blaine, Gresham, and Hay) who contended that the United States, by reason of its Constitution, could not recognize any distinction between American citizens in respect to their religion, successfully halted any steps to expel American citizens who happened to be Jews. As a result, it appeared that the rights of American citizens who were Jews became carefully guarded by the Turks. In 1897, some of the American delegates to the First Zionist Congress – Adam Rosenberg, Shepsel Schaffer, Rosa Sonnenschein, and Davis Treitsch, later made aliyah and greatly aided the new Zionist movement. By the next year, however, Americans, as well as other Jews who were not Ottoman citizens, were forced to seek assistance from their consuls in Palestine before their disembarkation in Jaffa.
THE POST-WAR PERIOD UNTIL THE WAR OF INDEPENDENCE
American members of the Jewish Delegation to the Versailles Peace Conference which argued for Jewish rights in Palestine and elsewhere included:
Joseph Barondess, prominent union leader in the US.Jacob de Haas, former secretary of the Federation of American Zionists.
Mary Fels, Zionist activist.
Bernard Flexner, attorney and philanthropist.
Felix Frankfurter, professor of law, legal advisor to the Delegation.
Dr. Harry Friedenwald, eye specdialist.
Jurist Julian Mack, who was also a member of the Zionist Commission (the settlement of Ramat Hashophet was named after him (1941)).
Louis Marshall, attorney and leader of the non-Zionists, who later helped to enlarge the Jewish Agency.
Louis Robison, treasurer of the Federation of American Zionists.
Nahman Syrkin, a leader of Poalei Tzion.
Stephen S. Wise, Zionist activist, leader of the Jewish community of the United States. As president of the American Jewish Congress, he was active on behalf of achieving Israeli independence. The settlement of Kfar Shmuel is named after him.
In the early years of the Zionist movement, great emphasis was placed on agricultural settlement. In 1908, an Ahuzah society, whose purpose was to purchase land in Palestine in order to establish new Jewish agricultural communities, was formed in St. Louis by Simon Goldman, formerly, the leader of Hoveve Zion in England. Soon, other Ahuza societies were formed throughout the US, from New York to Los Angeles. Sometimes, Goldman, himself, purchased plots of land with his own money – for example, Poriya in 1911, first settled by members of American Hehalutz, thus, becoming the first settlement founded entirely by Americans. In 1913, the Los Angeles Ahuza, and later, the LA branch of the Nathan Straus Palestine Advancement Society, attempted to purchase 17 acres of land in Palestine. This attempt failed due to the start of World War I, but in the post-war period, such efforts began anew. In 1924, the American branch of Mizrahi purchased land near Jerusalem that became the settlement of Neve Yaacov. In 1931, Gan Yavne was founded by the New York Ahuza and later, 12 members of the Detroit Kvutzah settled in Ramat Yohanan. Avihayil was founded by former fighters in the Jewish Legion in 1932. During the 1930s, as the numbers of American halutzim increased, many settled on, and integrated into, the kibbutzim that were newly established – Naan, Degania Bet, Ginnosar, Afikim, Ramat David, Givat Brenner, Mishmar haEmek. But sometimes, this wasn’t so easy. Many kibbutznikim considered Americans just too soft for the rigorous life of the kibbutz. Consequently, there were many cases of Americans being turned away from one kibbutz after another. Some became frustrated and disillusioned and either settled in the cities or returned to the US. But halutzim from America continued to arrive. In 1945, American Hashomer Hatzair established a dye-casting plant on land that later became the modern town of Hatzor. American halutzim also followed Palestinians in the settlement of the Negev (1946), in defiance of British law, and from that time and during the years immediately after independence, helped to settle Urim, Gal’on, and also Kfar Darom – totally obliterated by the Arab army of Egypt in 1948, obliterated for a second time by Ariel Sharon in 2005.
Since 1920, when 2 Americans were among those who fell defending the settlement of Tel Hai against Arab attackers, Americans have contributed greatly to the Yishuv’s defense - in the Haganah, Irgun, Lehi, Palmah, and Jewish Brigade. During World War II, many Jews in the US were active on behalf of the Zionist cause and of rescue efforts from Europe. As a result, the Emergency Committee for Zionist Affairs was established. The writer Ben Hecht, whose works were later banned in Britain due to his pro-Jewish activities, was active with the pro-Irgun Bergson Group under the Palestinian soldier/activist Peter Bergson, which sought to create a Jewish army of Diaspora and Palestinian Jews to fight the Nazis. Also due to his influence and Bergson’s, Hollywood and Broadway joined forces and organized the American League for a Free Palestine, and later, the American Arts Committee for Palestine. Because the Irgun played a major part in organizing these movements, and because Ben Gurion would often spread anti-Irgun propaganda, sometimes equating them with the Nazis, American Jewish organizations, in collaboration with the Roosevelt administration, would often attempt to silence them, both during and after the war. In spite of this, the Hecht/Bergson organizations had some influence with the US government. In 1944, the US War Refugee Board was established and sent one of its emissaries, Ira Hirschman, to neutral Turkey to help Jews escape from Europe. Several thousand were saved from certain death as a result, and many were helped to Palestine. Americans also aided in the struggle against the British blockade of “illegal” immigration, both during and after World War II, and also helped to fight off the impending British and Arab onslaughts in the months leading up to, and during, the War of Independence. New York Yiddish actress Stella Adler, in 1946, chartered a ship to take Holocaust refugees to Palestine. Other ships were also chartered by other sources. This activity was intensified later on and resulted in the formation of an organization known as the Machal – Diaspora Jewish and non-Jewish volunteers fighting for Israeli statehood and the right of Diaspora Jews to settle in their ancestral homeland. 3500 joined Machal including 1000 Americans, most notably:
Bill Bernstein of San Francisco was second mate on the Exodus 1947 which brought over 4000 Jewish refugees to Palestine but was intercepted by the British. He was clubbed to death by British soldiers who stormed the ship attempting to arrest the would-be immigrants.
Moshe Brodetzky, son of Palestinian refugees and formerly 2nd Lieutenant in Company E of the 5th Infantry during WWII for which he was awarded the Silver Star, became commander of Irgun forces on Mt. Zion.
US Naval Lt. Monroe Fein became captain of the ill-fated Irgun ship Altalena.
Murray Greenfield who had served in the US Merchant Marines during WWII and later became a leader in Aliyah Bet.
Stanley Andrews, from Los Angeles, MIA at Iraq el Sueidan, presumed dead, body never found.
Philip Balkin, from Los Angeles, killed at El Auja.
Lou Ball, NY, Iraq el Sueidan.
Spencer Boyd, St. Louis, near Nebi Rubin.
Bill Edmondson, Chicago, near Jerusalem.
Moshe Geberer, NY, near Jerusalem.
William Gerson and Glenn King, Los Angeles, killed in Mexico City while attempting to fly their C-46 to Israel.
Oliver Holton, Lakewood OH, and Alvin Levy, Long Beach NY, killed in a plane crash in the Sea of Galilee.
Joseph Kahn, Los Angeles, killed in Jerusalem fighting for the Irgun.
Jerome Kaplan, Bayonne, and Mandel Math, Brooklyn, both MIA after attacking Latrun.
Jacob Klein, NY, Kfar Menahem.
Ari Lashner, NY, Kfar Blum.
Baruch Linsky, NY, Hulda.
David Livingston, NY, Mishmar Haemek.
David “Mickey” Marcus, NY, killed by friendly fire near Abu Ghosh.
Harold Monash, NY, near Jerusalem.
Moshe Perlstein of Brooklyn, killed near the Etzion bloc.
Sam Pomerance, NY, while ferrying a Spitfire from Czechoslovakia to Israel, killed in a crash in the Yugoslav Alps.
Moe Rosenbaum, Brooklyn, near Ekron.
Jacob Rothman, Newark NJ, killed in a plane crash near Nice, France, on assignment for the Israeli Air Force.
Dov Seligman, Bronx, Ein Dor.
Irving Sevin, Chicago, killed on a mountain trail between Maayan Baruch and Safed.
Jack Shulman, NY, Beersheba.
Edward Troyen, NY, wounded in a flying mission, later died.
Bob Vickman, Los Angeles, killed in a plane crash during a mission over the El Arish region.
The following is a partial list of prominent American Jews, mainly olim but also those who live in the US, who have made valuable contributions to various spheres of Israeli society, both before and after independence.
LAND RECLAMATION
Moses Alexander of New York, founded the Ohale Moshe neighborhood in Jerusalem in 1901.
Ben Ami Carter, made aliyah in the mid 60s as leader of the Black Hebrew Israelites who claimed descent from the Ten Lost Tribes of Israel.
Anita Tucker, Gush Katif activist, brutally expelled from her home under orders of PM Sharon in 2005.
Meir Bar Ilan, leader of the American branch of Mizrahi, moved to Palestine in 1926 and became one of the leading representatives of the Palestinian Mizrahi in the Vaad Leumi.
After independence:
Steven Adler, National Labor Court Judge.
Justice Louis Brandeis of the US Supreme Court, though he did not make aliyah, was an active Zionist and champion of private enterprise both in Palestine and the US. The settlement Ein Hashofet was established and named after him, ironically, by the American branch of the socialist Hashomer Hatzair movement.
Stanley Fischer, governor of the Bank of Israel.
Dr. Louis Cantor, pioneer in sanitation.
After independence:
Dr. David Appelbaum, internationally respected Emergency Room Director of the Shaare Tzedek Hospital in Jerusalem when he was killed by an Arab suicide bomber at a café in Jerusalem in 2003. His death inspired a group of American doctors to make aliyah.
Albert Einstein visited the Hebrew University in 1923, was long involved with its development. Upon the death of Chaim Weizmann in 1952, he was approached to succeed him as president of Israel. He politely turned down the request.
After independence:
Carl Alpert, vice-chairman of the Technion’s Board of Governors.
Cyrus Adler, a Jew from Arkansas, came to Palestine in 1890 as Antiquities Commissioner for the proposed Columbian Exposition in Chicago to collect local archaeological exhibits.
Judith Green, prominent archeologist.
Peretz Hirschbein and Halpern Leivick, socialist Yiddish writers became champions of the kibbutz movement upon their visits to Palestine in 1929 and 1937 respectively.
After independence:
Scholem Asch, Yiddish writer, made aliyah in 1956 and after his death the following year, the Scholem Asch Museum in Bat Yam was founded in his memory.
Caroline Glick, journalist, contributor to the Jerusalem Post.
ART
Hy Mayer, animator, created short animation films of Palestine during World War I.
After independence:
Leonard Bernstein conducted his first Israeli concert in 1947; thereafter, he often made guest appearances with the Israel Philharmonic Orchestra. Other musicians who often collaborated with the Orchestra since its founding in 1936 included Emanuel Feuerman, Leopold Godowsky, and Pierre Monteaux.
After independence:
Mike Burstyn, popular actor and entertainer. Famous for his Kuni Lemml character in the 70s.
The Kabbalah Centre, established in Jerusalem, in 1922 and then in Los Angeles under Phillip Berg in 1969, recently began to look into buying property in the town of Rosh Pina near the Kabbalah capital of Safed. Through the dissemination of its teachings by such celebrities as Roseanne Barr and especially Madonna (both of whom also looked into buying property in Israel), Kabbalah achieved great popularity in Hollywood and Hollywood Kabbalists have maintained close spiritual, if not physical ties, to Israel. Other present or former high-profile devotees include: David and Victoria Beckham (LA residents as of this writing), Sandra Bernhard, Naomi Campbell, Laura Dern, Sarah Ferguson Duchess of York (US resident), David Geffen, Jeff Goldblum, Linda Gray, Jerry Hall, Goldie Hawn, Paris Hilton, Diane Keaton, Ashton Kutcher and Demi Moore, Lindsay Lohan, Courtney Love, Alanis Morissette, Gwyneth Paltrow, Guy Ritchie, Winona Ryder, Britney Spears, Barbra Streisand, Elizabeth Taylor.
The Benny Leonard Club was founded in 1923 and for many years, it was the foremost club for champion Palestinian boxers.
After independence:
Tom Almadon, goalkeeper for Macabi Haifa.